Stainless Steel Vs ABS Plastic Water Purifier: Which is better?

Did you know that 99.99% of bacteria can be removed with a water purifier? But not all storage tanks are created equal. Stainless steel tanks are superior to ABS plastic when it comes to safety, durability, and water quality. In this blog post, I will explore why stainless steel may be a good choice for storing purified water, examining aspects such as leaching, bacterial growth, durability, and maintenance, to help you make an informed decision.

Which is safer for storing purified water: stainless steel or ABS plastic?

Storing purified water requires careful consideration of the storage material to ensure the water remains safe and free from contamination. Two popular options are stainless steel and ABS plastic. While both have their advantages and disadvantages, stainless steel is generally considered safer for storing purified water.

Water released through the RO membrane eliminates the remaining disinfectants such as chlorine. What this causes is that the water contained in the ABS plastic tank is exposed to microbial proliferation. And in the covering of the stored water tank, this affects the growth of bacterial colonisation, as shown in this study.

Want the basics first? Compare SCMT, RO, UV, MF and UF Water Purifiers

Nonetheless, in modern-day water purifiers, the UV disinfectants are available in the water tanks. The advantage of this is that it will sterilise the water UV-wise before dispensing it, therefore a bacterial growth cannot take place. The technology is mainly found in Kent RO water purifiers and it is also found in several Aquaguard models.

For servicing, see our Kent Vs Aquaguard RO AMC Comparison.

Safety Comparison

MaterialLeachingCorrosionCleaningBacterial Growth
Stainless SteelNoNoEasyLow
ABS PlasticPossiblePossibleDifficultHigh

Stainless steel does not leach chemicals into the water, unlike ABS plastic which can potentially release styrene monomer, a known carcinogen. Additionally, stainless steel does not corrode, ensuring the water remains safe and free from contamination. Cleaning stainless steel tanks is also easier and less prone to causing abrasions compared to ABS plastic tanks. Furthermore, stainless steel is less susceptible to bacterial growth, maintaining the water’s purity.

This infographic shows details about factors accelerating plastic leaching

Factors Accelerating Plastic Leaching infographics

Tank transparency and convenience

ABS plastic tanks are transparent, allowing you to easily check the quality of both the water and the tank itself.

ABS Plastic and Stainless Steel Tank transparency comparison

In contrast, stainless steel water purifiers have concealed tanks that are not transparent, but the good news is that these tanks are removable and washable.

For example,

The Aquaguard Aura water purifier features an ABS plastic tank that is durable, lightweight, and easy to clean.  This tank has a high storage capacity of 7 litres, ensuring a constant supply of purified water.  

In contrast, the LG Puricare water purifier boasts a concealed, removable stainless steel tank.  The concealed design of the LG tank also enhances the overall aesthetic appeal of the purifier. 

Hidden Risk of Airtight RO Tanks When the Membrane Fails

For the last three months, our water purifier had been behaving strangely. It was dispensing about 60 to 70 ml of water and then shutting off automatically. We thought this was happening due to some pressure issues, and since the water purifier’s life indicator wasn’t showing red.

We called a technician, and he found that there were issues with the RO membrane. Water was not passing through the RO membrane properly, which caused it to shut off automatically. He also mentioned that only the UV lamp and pre-filters were working, so the TDS of the input and output water was coming out to be almost the same.

The TDS reading that gave it away

The best way to check whether an RO water purifier is working properly is to measure the TDS of its input water and output water.

At our place, the TDS for both the input and output water was showing between 165 and 170 ppm. However, a healthy RO membrane cuts TDS by 85% to 95%. Since the TDS of the input and output water at our place was coming out completely the same, it means either the RO membrane has failed or the RO membrane is being bypassed.

Input water TDS measured straight from the tap
Input water TDS measured straight from the tap
Output Water TDS after cleaning the tank
Output Water TDS after cleaning the tank

What the sealed tank looked like inside

The best way to check whether an RO water purifier is working properly is to measure the TDS of its input water and output water.

At our place, the TDS for both the input and output water was showing between 165 and 170 ppm. However, a healthy RO membrane cuts TDS by 85% to 95%. Since the TDS of the input and output water at our place was coming out completely the same, it means either the RO membrane has failed or the RO membrane is being bypassed.

Impurities had settled across the entire tank, including the seams and joints
Impurities had settled across the entire tank, including the seams and joints
Iron residue and impurities deposited on the tank wall
Iron residue and impurities deposited on the tank wall
Impurities and foam visible in the stored water during cleaning
Impurities and foam visible in the stored water during cleaning
Iron residue coating the float of the water level sensor, which can also affect how accurately the purifier reads the water level
Iron residue coating the float of the water level sensor, which can also affect how accurately the purifier reads the water level

Because we were not getting a red notification light, it means the RO membrane is fine, but the water is bypassing the RO membrane. Additionally, the iron content in our input water is very high, which appeared to be the root cause of the entire problem.

Iron residue picked up on the first wipe of the tank interior
Iron residue picked up on the first wipe of the tank interior
A plain white cloth after wiping the same tank: the brown staining is iron
A plain white cloth after wiping the same tank: the brown staining is iron

Why an airtight tank makes the problem harder to catch

The problem starts here when the RO membrane fails, and impurities flow from the input water and reach directly into the tank. When impurities from the input water reach directly into the water storage tank, you ignore it. Even if you fix the issue, you still end up ignoring this part.

Aquaguard Enrich Ritz Pro sealed SS 304 stainless steel tank with airtight screwed lid
Aquaguard Enrich Ritz Pro sealed SS 304 stainless steel tank with airtight screwed lid

Another reason for this is that the stainless steel tank in the water purifier is completely sealed and cannot be seen from the outside. So, you don’t properly know what is inside.

True, a stainless steel tank is very good and is a better material. It neither leaches nor corrodes; even if the temperature goes above 50 degrees, it does not leach. However, if your RO membrane fails and your water purifier does not have the technology to completely shut down upon RO failure – meaning it continues to dispense water little by little – you end up ignoring it.

Whether it is a stainless steel tank or an ABS plastic tank, the manufacturer seals the tank with good intentions so that no insects, dust, or any other contaminants can enter it.

Keeping this very reason in mind, the company has fully concealed the tank along with the body panel. In some cases, it is fully concealed, while in others, you can open it by removing the screws. However, the design works exactly as intended, as long as such a problem.

How to avoid tank contamination if the membrane fails.

Check input and output TDS, not output. When the two readings are not far apart, the membrane is not functioning properly whether the purifier light indicates so or not.

If there is a dramatic decrease in dispensed volume, it’s a red flag. The first sign was our purifier that stopped at 60 to 70ml, before taking any action, 3 months later.

What manufacturers need to improve

I believe there are two design modifications that will solve most of this problem, and none are very difficult. Three or four design modifications, I think, will correct most of this problem and none are particularly difficult.

Impurity Sensors and Alarms:

Nowadays, many smart water purifiers have started coming onto the market. In these, you get to see an inbuilt TDS meter that shows the TDS of the input water and output water on the display. This is found in many brands, such as Aquaguard, the M3 models from the Native company, and nowadays it is also seen in Kent. Getting the TDS readings of the input water and output water helps you know how well your water purifier is functioning.

This is a good step taken by the companies. I also feel that companies should keep in mind that if impurities enter the tank, there should be a sensor and an alarm to detect them, because many water purifier users do not pay attention to such technical details.

Easy detachment tanks:

This includes whether the tank is stainless steel or ABS plastic, and that it can be removed without the need for a screwdriver, allowing the user to wash it himself or herself instead of waiting for a yearly service visit.

Which is more durable: stainless steel or ABS plastic Tank?

The durability of a water purifier’s storage tank is a crucial consideration for home use. In this regard, stainless steel tanks outperform ABS plastic tanks in several aspects.

Durability Comparison

MaterialDurabilityLifespan
Stainless SteelVastly more durable15+ years
ABS PlasticProne to cracks and leaks3-5 years

Stainless steel tanks are designed to withstand the rigors of daily use, with a lifespan of over 15 years if properly maintained. In contrast, ABS plastic tanks are more susceptible to damage, typically lasting only 3-5 years before requiring replacement.

Does a stainless steel tank in a water purifier affect the taste of water?

The stainless steel tank in a water purifier plays a crucial role in maintaining the taste of water. Stainless steel tanks are made from food-grade materials that prevent corrosion and ensure the purity of stored water. This is particularly important in water purification systems where the taste of water can be affected by various contaminants and impurities.

Studies have shown that stainless steel tanks can significantly improve the taste of water by reducing the presence of impurities and contaminants. For instance, a study conducted by Eureka Forbes found that water purifiers with stainless steel tanks can remove up to 99.99% of impurities, resulting in cleaner and better-tasting water (Source: eurekaforbes.com).

In addition to removing impurities, stainless steel tanks also help to maintain the natural pH balance of water. This is important because water with an unnatural pH balance can have an unpleasant taste. For example, water with a high pH level can have a bitter or metallic taste, while water with a low pH level can have a sour or acidic taste.

Also explore our Top alkaline RO water purifiers.

Here is a table summarizing the benefits of stainless steel tanks in water purifiers:

FeatureBenefits
Corrosion-resistantPrevents contamination and ensures purity
Food-grade materialsEnsures water safety and hygiene
pH balance maintenanceMaintains natural pH balance, improving taste
Impurity removalRemoves up to 99.99% of impurities

Is an ABS plastic Tank in a Water Purifier a good insulator for keeping water cool?

ABS plastic is a popular material used in various applications, including water purifiers. One of the key functions of a water purifier is to keep the water cool, which is where ABS plastic’s insulation properties come into play.

ABS plastic is known for its high-temperature resistance, chemical resistance, and ageing resistance, making it an excellent insulator for water purifiers. In terms of thermal insulation, ABS plastic has a relatively low thermal conductivity, which means it is a poor conductor of heat.

This property makes it suitable for applications where thermal insulation is desired, such as in water purifiers.

According to a study by SendCutSend, ABS plastic has a thermal conductivity of 0.11 to 0.25 W/m·K, which is significantly lower than other materials like copper (386 W/m·K) or aluminium (237 W/m·K) (Source: sendcutsend.com).

In addition to its thermal insulation properties, ABS plastic is also resistant to chemicals and corrosion, which is important for water purifiers that often come into contact with various chemicals and contaminants.

ABS plastic’s chemical resistance is due to its low permeability rate, which prevents damage caused by liquids leaking inside the material (Source: yijinsolution.com).

Thermal Conductivity of ABS Plastic and Other Materials

MaterialThermal Conductivity (W/m·K)
ABS Plastic0.11-0.25
Copper386
Aluminum237
Steel50-60
Glass1.3-2.3

Note: The thermal conductivity values are approximate and may vary depending on the specific grade and formulation of the material.

Why Stainless Steel tank water purifier is more expensive than ABS plastic tank water purifier?

Stainless steel tank water purifiers are generally more expensive than ABS plastic tank water purifiers due to several factors. The primary reason is the material cost of stainless steel, which is significantly higher than ABS plastic.

According to a study, the cost of stainless steel is approximately 3.5 times higher than ABS plastic. This increased cost is reflected in the final product, making stainless steel water purifiers more expensive upfront.

Another factor contributing to the higher cost is the manufacturing process. Stainless steel requires a more complex and labour-intensive manufacturing process, which increases production costs. In contrast, ABS plastic can be moulded into various shapes and forms with relative ease, reducing production costs.

Additionally, stainless steel water purifiers often come with advanced features such as multi-stage filtration systems and UV treatment, which further increase their cost.

These features provide better water quality and purification, but they also add to the overall expense of the product.

Here is a comparison of the costs:

MaterialCost per Unit
ABS Plastic₹ 5,000 – ₹ 10,000
Stainless Steel₹ 15,000 – ₹ 30,000

Which is easier to clean and maintain: Stainless steel or ABS plastic tank?

When it comes to cleaning and maintenance, stainless steel water purifiers have a significant edge over their ABS plastic counterparts.

Stainless steel tanks are naturally hygienic and easy to clean, requiring only soap and water to maintain their pristine condition.

KENT Pearl RO Transparent ABS Plastic Tank
KENT Pearl RO Transparent ABS Plastic Tank

In contrast, ABS plastic tanks require more frequent and thorough cleaning to prevent bacterial growth and biofilm accumulation (Source: bepure.store).

Cleaning and Maintenance Comparison

MaterialEase of CleaningMaintenance Frequency
Stainless SteelEasyLess frequent
ABS PlasticDifficultMore frequent

Stainless steel tanks are less prone to bacterial infections and corrosion, making them a more sanitary choice for water storage.

Concealed stainless steel tank Tank in LG Puricare
Concealed stainless steel tank Tank in LG Puricare

Additionally, their durability ensures they can withstand high and low temperatures, pressure, and UV radiation without compromising their integrity. 

In contrast, ABS plastic tanks are more susceptible to damage from UV radiation and extreme weather conditions, requiring more frequent cleaning and protection (Source: echemi.com).

See our Top Water purifiers with low maintenance cost.

Is ABS plastic Tank Water Purifier susceptible to bacterial growth?

ABS plastic tank water purifiers are susceptible to bacterial growth, which can compromise the quality of treated water.

According to a study, the bacterial diversity of effluent water from different purifiers showed that Proteobacteria were relatively abundant in influent water samples from purifier C, while Melainabacteria dominated in sample B-E (Source: iue.cas.cn). This highlights the potential for bacterial growth in these systems.

The presence of bacteria in drinking water can lead to various problems, including hygienic, aesthetic, and operational issues. Factors such as type and concentration of available organic and inorganic nutrients, residual disinfectant, and environmental conditions like water temperature influence bacterial growth and interactions (Source: frontiersin.org). A study found that assimilable organic carbon (AOC) levels above 100 µg/L can support significant bacterial growth (Source: besjournal.com).

Table 3 from the study on microbial contamination of household water purifiers shows that the top 50 genera in bacteria communities include Bacterium clone SRAO 22, Reyranella sp., and Paenibacillus borealis, with some genera exhibiting high abundance in effluent water and membrane samples. 

This underscores the need for effective control measures to prevent bacterial growth in ABS plastic tank water purifiers.

Urvashi Chakravarty
Urvashi Chakravarty

Urvashi Chakravarty, an expert in water chemistry and purification systems, founded the data-driven blog WaterPurifierInsights.in to help people understand water quality. After earning a degree in Hydrochemistry, she gained hands-on experience by working on farms inspecting TDS levels and water chemistry. Chakravarty later transitioned to installing large reverse osmosis systems for industry and homes. Driven by her passion for educating people on water quality, she started the blog to provide authoritative insights on water purifiers using her expertise. She offers reliable tips and advice grounded in her background in water chemistry and experience with purification systems.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a reply

      Water Purifier Clarity -
      WaterPurifierInsights.in

      Get the full picture on water purifiers - compare models, learn maintenance tips, and monitor TDS - at WaterPurifierInsights.in

      Contact Us

      House no 18 B, near Tipsi bowl, Bhangagarh, Guwahati, India

      support@waterpurifierinsights.in

      Office Time

      9AM - 4PM
      (Sunday closed)

      Connect

      Facebook
      Twitter
      Instagram

      Disclaimer: waterpurifierinsights.in is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.in

      WaterpurifierInsights - Purely Tested, Truly Trusted: Your Go-To Guide for Data-Driven Water Purifier Reviews and Pro Tips
      Logo